Skip to main content

Winner of the Edgerton Foundation New Play Award

What if your first crush really was perfect? From the comic genius of Cinco Paul (Despicable Me and the musical hit of the summer Schmigadoon) and Bekah Brunstetter (This Is Us) comes the delightfully witty, sublimely inspiring story of teenaged Mary Magdalene, who falls in love with the carpenter’s son next door… who happens to be a kid named Jesus. In her quest to impress him, Mary has to fend off a trio of 1st-Century Mean Girls and a bunch of Beastie Boys-inspired wiseguys from the Sanhedrin. She learns that getting Jesus to love you back is both easier – and harder – than she ever imagined.  With a lush R&B score and a riotous cast of characters, A.D. 16 achieves the rare feat of being both funny and sincere. A thrilling and fun musical for people of all faiths, or no faith at all.

Starring Phoenix Best (Dear Evan Hansen) as Mary and Ben Fankhauser (Disney's Newsies) as Jesus

Scenic Designer Walt Spangler • Costume Designer Emilio Sosa • Lighting Designer Colin K. Bills • Sound Designer Matt Rowe • Wig Designer Anne Nesmith • Production Stage Manager Karen Currie

Presented in association with Sloane Productions, LLC

Book by
Bekah Brunstetter

Music & Lyrics by
Cinco Paul

Story by
Cinco Paul

Director
Stephen Brackett

Choreographer
Katie Spelman

Music Director
Christopher Youstra

Orchestrations/Music Supervisor
Doug Besterman

2021-2022 Season
Part of the 2021-2022 Season
  • Colin K. Bills

    Lighting Designer
  • Stephen Brackett

    Director
  • Bekah Brunstetter

    Book
  • Karen Currie

    Production Stage Manager
  • Cinco Paul

    Music, Lyrics and Story
  • Matt Rowe

    Sound Designer
  • Emilio Sosa

    Costume Designer
  • Walt Spangler

    Scenic Designer
  • Katie Spelman

    Choreographer
  • Christopher Youstra

    Music Director

Production Sponsorship

  • This project is supported in part by an award from the National Endowment for the Arts.

Supported in part by the Frank Young Fund for New Musicals, a program of National Alliance for Musical Theatre, with funding from The Hollywood Pantages, a Nederlander Organization - namt.org.

Health and Safety

We ask that if you are experiencing symptoms, please stay home. Use this CDC symptom checklist to see if you need to quarantine or get tested.

PROOF OF COVID-19 VACCINATION

Masks and proof of COVID vaccination are required to attend for all patrons. Exemptions may be made for those who are not vaccinated, such as children under 5, people with certain medical conditions preventing vaccination, or those with closely held religious beliefs. These patrons must provide proof of a timely negative Covid-19 PCR test taken within 48 hours or a rapid antigen test taken within six hours of showtime. Feel free to email info@olneytheatre.org with questions. 

Along with a photo ID, please be prepared to show one of the following proofs of vaccination:

  • You may present either your original vaccine card, a legible digital or hard copy
  • You may present one of the commonly used vaccine passport apps that verify both your vaccination status and i.d. such as Health PassBindleVaxYes
  • Digital vaccination cards through your home Health Department (check with your state/county’s Health Department if not listed here): MarylandDCVirginia

Visit our Health and Safety page for our latest policies to keep you safe as we return to the stage!

A.D. 16

February 4 - March 6 2022

Buy Tickets

Box Office: 301.924.3400

Open Wednesday - Saturday: 12:00PM - 6:00PM

Mailing list

Keep up to date with our latest events & offers:

Join our mailing list