Skip to main content
Toggle menu Search Cart

Featuring Tom Story as the D'Ysquiths and Jacob Tischler as Monty

This Tony Award winner for Best Musical is a hilarious and lyrical satire of money, manners, morals, and, yes, murder. After his mother’s death, Monty Navarro (Singin' in the Rain's Jacob Tischler) is shocked and delighted to learn that she had a secret: she’s related to the absurdly wealthy and aristocratic D’Ysquith family. And if, at first, Monty hoped his new relations might provide a sorely needed cash infusion, as eighth in line to the title of Earl of Highhurst, there isn’t much hope for him inheriting the family treasure. When Monty’s reunion with one of his long-lost kinfolk suddenly results in him moving into seventh place, he wonders to himself, “Why stop there?” Thus begins one of the funniest and most outrageous murder sprees in musical theatre history. Even better, in this production, all seven ill-fated D’Ysquiths are played by DMV-favorite Tom Story (Mrs. Trunchbull in Matilda).

Bloodlust hasn’t sung so sweetly, or provided so much theatrical fun, since Sweeney Todd first wielded his razor” – The New York Times
 

Music by Steven Lutvak
Lyrics by Steven Lutvak and Robert L. Freedman
Book by Robert L. Freedman
Music Directed by Christopher Youstra
Choreographed by Ashleigh King
Directed by Eleanor Holdridge

 

2025-26 Season
Part of the 2025-26 Season

Inside Rehearsal: Why Are All The D'Ysquiths Dying?

Press and Reviews

  • "Wily comic bits in [a] lark of a production [with] clever lyrics [and a] tuneful orchestra [that] recalls Gilbert and Sullivan and wistful or go-for-broke music hall numbers. " - DC Theater Arts
  • "A bold, showy production of one of the sharpest musical farces of the 21st century" - BroadwayWorld
  • "A fast-paced show that will keep you laughing the entire time." - MD Theatre Guide
  • "[From the] scenic design, to the sublime multi-leveled performance of Tom Story as eight members of the aristocratic D'Ysquith family, this production dazzles." - Talkin' Broadway
  • "A Gentleman's Guide... at Olney is a killer!" - OUTspoken
  • Tom Story

    The D'Ysquith Family
  • Jacob Tischler

    Monty Navarro
  • Donna Migliaccio

    Miss Shingle
  • Sumié Yotsukura

    Sibella Hallward
  • Sadie Koopman

    Phoebe D'Ysquith
  • Simone Ballinger-Brown

    Ensemble, U/S Phoebe
  • Anna Maria C. Ferrari

    Ensemble, U/S Sibella, Dance Captain
  • Benjamin Lurye

    Ensemble, U/S Monty
  • Canter Irene O'May

    Ensemble/US The D’Ysquith Family
  • Decarlo J. Raspberry

    Ensemble
  • Karen Vincent

    Ensemble, U/S Miss Shingle
  • Wynter Nicole Cook

    Swing
  • Michael E. McGovern

    Swing
  • Robert L. Freedman

    Book and Lyrics
  • Steven Lutvak

    Music & Lyrics
  • Eleanor Holdridge

    Director
  • Ashleigh King

    Choreographer
  • Christopher Youstra

    Music Director/Director of Music Theater
  • John Coyne

    Scenic Designer
  • Sarah Cubbage

    Costume Designer
  • Minjoo Kim

    Lighting Designer
  • Matthew Rowe

    Sound Designer
  • Zavier Augustus Lee Taylor

    Projections Designer
  • Ben Walsh

    Production Stage Manager
  • Rebecca Talisman

    Stage Manager
  • Sara Gehl

    Assistant Stage Manager
  • Debbie Ellinghaus

    Executive Director, Olney Theatre Center
  • Jason Loewith

    Artistic Director, Olney Theatre Center

Community Events

Story Time at the Olney Library

  • Sunday, July 12th, 
    2:00–3:00 p.m.
    Location: Olney Public Library (3500 Olney Laytonsville Rd, Olney, MD 20832)
    Story reader: Liz Osborn

    No RSVP. Just show up! 

The Art of the Execution: Behind the Scenes of Gentleman's Guide

  • Date: Sun., July 5, 5:00-6:00 p.m.
    Location: Roberts Mainstage
    $10 / Free for members 

     

    It takes a staggering amount of quick changes and machinery—and a healthy dose of mischief—to orchestrate the perfect crime. Take part in a fascinating, behind-the-scenes exploration of the Tony Award-winning musical A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder. We will be joined by the Director Eleanor Holdridge and our very own Director of Production, Jerid Fox; Chris Youstra, Associate Artistic Director of Music Theatre and Music Director; and Associate Artistic Director Hallie Gordon - our "agents in charge" - who will trace the show's brilliant DNA back to its roots. 

    We'll explore the grand tradition of Gilbert & Sullivan’s satirical operettas and the high-octane world of Vaudeville that demands a single, virtuoso performer to inhabit an entire family tree. Learn some of the secrets of the show's precise physical comedy and discover how complex, modern stage machinery drives this fast-paced, killer comedy forward.

Community Choirs

Before select performances of  A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder, the Cafritz Lobby will come alive with the sounds of local choral ensembles. Join us early to enjoy these talented community groups sharing their music in celebration of the show.

These pre-show concerts are free and open to everyone—no ticket required.

 

Friday, July 3, 2026
6:45 - 7:15pm
Rockville Chorus, Inc. is a vibrant and dedicated musical organization consisting of 75 adult volunteer singers who perform a wide variety of musical genres and styles of choral music, embracing everything from classical and contemporary works to folk, jazz, and pop arrangements. Through dynamic performances, community engagement, and a passion for musical excellence, this choral group brings people together to share in the joy of song! 

 

Saturday, July 18, 2026
6:45 - 7:15pm 
Bushwick Book Club is the joyous intersection of indie artists and book nerds where a group of artists create new work inspired by a particular work of literature.  Started in 2009 in the Bushwick neighborhood of Brooklyn, NY, there are now 8 active chapters around the world.  The DC Chapter started in 2022. Unlike any “Book Club” you’ve ever experienced, this local group has created a new work - music and an animation - based on  Israel Rank:  The Autobiography of a Criminal, the source material for A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder. It’s a pre-show experience you don’t want to miss.   

 

Sunday, August 2, 2026
12:45 - 1:15pm
Singchronicity, formed as a performance quartet rather than a competition quartet, has been delighting audiences since 2012. Members of the group have previously sung in symphony choruses, church choirs, college and high school a cappella choirs, a high school barbershop quartet, and musical theater. All four are proud members of the Capital Accord Chorus in Silver Spring, MD. In February 2018 Singchronicity had the good fortune to be featured on WAMU, Washington, D.C.’s public radio station, as part of a Valentine’s Day segment. Although they have diverse musical backgrounds, friendship and ringing chords unite them. 

 

Friday, August 21, 2026
6:45 - 7:15pm
Heart of Maryland is a men's chorus singing primarily in the barbershop style, singing songs ranging from oldies to doowop (50's and 60's) right up through the modern-day. We strive to be members of the community, singing at events around Baltimore and its surrounding counties. This includes providing entertainment at festivals, fairs, luncheons and retirement villages. We also have a competitive nature and sing in competitions with choruses across the Mid-Atlantic region.One thing is for sure, The Heart of Maryland Chorus does a lot of things together, but the most important thing that we enjoy doing is having a whole lot of fun! 

Onstage Tours

How does a professional theater bring the magic of a story on stage? We’re inviting folks of every age to come on stage and see how we do it. Lighting demonstrations, costume and prop displays, scenery moves… our professional production staff will take you on an amazing Onstage Tour.  

RSVP early; this event tends to sell out fast!

“Embodying Character Through Dance” with A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder Choreographer Ashleigh King

  • Date: Monday, July 20, 2026, 7:00 - 8:30 pm

    Location: Dance Studio

    Cost: $25

    After dancing on Olney Theatre Center’s stages in Singin’ in the Rain, Matilda, the Musical, and more, Ashleigh King is now choreographing for our productions, including our upcoming summer musical, A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder. The class will be structured to challenge experienced movers and dancers by building on your existing technique, style, and performance quality, but quick-learners of all levels are welcome. Come join Ashleigh for a fast-paced and enjoyable deep dive into character work through dance.

Get the Olney Theatre Mobile App

  • See all your upcoming events

    Manage your tickets, download them to your Apple or Google Wallet, and easily share them with friends

    Access digital programs

    Watch the latest videos

    Receive notifications and reminders

    Available in iOS and Android

    Learn
     more on our blog

A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder

July 2 - August 23 2026

Buy Tickets

Box Office: 301.924.3400

Open Wednesday - Sunday: 12:00 PM - 6:00 PM

Mailing list

Keep up to date with our latest events & offers:

Join our mailing list